Plato s Euthyphro The Moral Debate Between
Socrates then says that since Euthyphro knows exactly what holiness is, he must know what characteristic s a thing must have in order for it to qualify as something holy. But in the end Euthyphro cannot say what characteristics a thing must have in order for it to be holy. Although Socrates does not explicitly say so, it is clear what his conclusion is: Euthyphro does not know what holiness is.
And the reasons or premises that support this conclusion are also pretty clear: If Euthyphro knew what holiness is, he would know what characteristics a thing must have in order for it to be holy, but Euthyphro does not know what characteristics a thing must have in order for it to be holy. If Euthyphro knew what holiness is, then he would know what characteristics a thing must have in Dbate for it to be holy.
But Euthyphro does not know what characteristics a thing must have in order for it to be holy. Listing the premises and conclusion of an argument in this way is the standard way of stating an argument.
Expert's Answer
You will probably agree that premise 2 is true since in the dialogue Euthyphro clearly cannot say what characteristics qualify a thing as holy. But is premise 1 true? Is it true that if a person knows what something is, then he or she must know what characteristics a thing must have in order to be that kind of thing?
Think about a specific example: Is it true that if you know what a dog is, then you must know what characteristics a thing must have in order for Plato s Euthyphro The Moral Debate Between to be a dog? Is it possible for a person to know what a dog is, without being able to say exactly what characteristics make it a dog?
In other words, can you know what a thing is, even though you cannot define it? Nov 17 AM Solution. Questions Courses. Therefore, Euthyphro does not know what holiness is.
Nov 17 AM. Expert's Answer Solution. Feedback :.
Plagiarism Checker
Next Previous. Related Questions. Read the Euthyphro, and write a paper in which you do the following: a. Explain how the concept of Explain how the concept of holiness emerges in the dialogue and why it takes a prominent position in the conversation between Socrates and Euthyphro. Present the three This essay will not only test your ability to recognize and engage philosophical concepts and analysis, but also brings you into the dialogue as a participant, asking This debate took place outside of the Hare uses a version of the Golden Rule to show that abortion is usually Plato s Euthyphro The Moral Debate Between wrong. What version. What version of the Golden Rule does he use? Marguis argues that abortion is wrong for the same reason that we feel killing Euthypheo adult Betweeh wrong, Marguis argues that abortion is wrong for the same reason that we feel killing an adult is wrong, that is, it deprives the click of the value that their future life would have.
Suppose you agree Can you explain why her views cannot be classified as utilitarian?
Navigation menu
Do you see any similarities between her Put each of her five traits into your own words. Rachels offers a Imagine yourself in the position she suggests: You are an alien who has landed on a planet and want. Imagine yourself in the position she suggests: You are an alien who has landed on a planet and want to know whether the creatures you see are persons with a moral right to life, or whether it is morally right to kill and eat them.]
In my opinion you have misled.
I join. So happens. Let's discuss this question. Here or in PM.